New Manager, Same Result? Man Utd Ratings

kobexielite 𝕯𝖎𝖌𝖎𝖙𝖆𝖑 𝕸𝖊𝖉𝖎𝖆

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Dec 23, 2024

41 visitor like this post

Share

New Manager, Same Result? Man Utd Ratings: A Disappointing Season

Manchester United. The name conjures images of glory, of legendary players, and of consistent success. Yet, the 2023-2024 season, despite the arrival of a new manager, has painted a rather different picture. While hopes were high for a dramatic turnaround, the reality on the pitch has been, for many, a continuation of the frustrating inconsistency that has plagued the club for years. Let's delve into the performances and assess the individual player ratings.

The Erik ten Hag Era: A Mixed Bag

Erik ten Hag’s appointment was met with cautious optimism. His Ajax pedigree suggested a tactical acumen capable of transforming United’s fortunes. However, while some aspects of his philosophy have been implemented, the overall results haven't consistently matched the expectation. The team has shown flashes of brilliance, exhibiting the pressing style and attacking fluidity that defined his Ajax teams. But these moments of quality have been interspersed with periods of alarming sloppiness, leaving fans questioning whether the Dutchman is the right man to steer the ship back to the top.

Key Players: Overperforming or Underwhelming?

Individual player ratings remain a contentious topic amongst fans, with significant variation depending on the game and the individual's contribution. It's impossible to provide definitive numbers without considering each match individually, but we can discuss overall trends and highlight key performers (and underperformers):

• Andre Onana: The Cameroonian goalkeeper has generally impressed with his distribution and shot-stopping, showing composure beyond his years. His rating would likely hover around a solid 7.0 - 7.5 on average. His decision-making, however, remains a potential area for improvement.

• Raphael Varane: When fit, Varane delivers world-class performances. His leadership and composure are vital. However, his injury record continues to be a concern, limiting his overall contribution. Ratings fluctuate significantly depending on availability, but when healthy, he's easily an 8.0+ player.

• Lisandro Martínez: The Argentinian's tenacity and aggression have injected much-needed steel into the United defense. His short stature is sometimes exploited, but his overall impact earns him a consistent 7.0 - 7.5 rating.

• Bruno Fernandes: The Portuguese playmaker remains a vital cog in the United midfield, contributing goals and assists regularly. However, his temperament and occasional inconsistency affect his overall rating, fluctuating between 6.5 and 8.0 depending on his performance.

• Marcus Rashford: Rashford has shown glimpses of his immense talent, but inconsistency continues to plague him. While capable of match-winning performances, his overall contribution has been less than stellar, resulting in a rating fluctuating between 6.0 and 7.5.

The Bigger Picture: Systemic Issues Persist

The problem at Manchester United is not simply a matter of individual player ratings. Deep-rooted systemic issues continue to hinder the team's progress. These include:

• Inconsistency: The team's ability to deliver consistently high-level performances remains a significant challenge.

• Defensive Fragility: Despite improvements, defensive lapses still occur too frequently, costing crucial points.

• Lack of a Consistent Goalscoring Threat: While Rashford has potential, a more reliable goalscorer is crucial.

Conclusion: A Long Road Ahead

The arrival of Erik ten Hag has brought some positive changes to Manchester United, but the team remains far from its potential. Individual player ratings are only part of the story. Addressing the deeper systemic issues will be key to achieving sustainable success. Until then, the frustrating cycle of highs and lows is likely to continue. The road to redemption remains long and arduous. The question remains: Will next season bring a different result? Only time will tell.