One Doom's Dark Ages: A Setback

kobexielite 𝕯𝖎𝖌𝖎𝖙𝖆𝖑 𝕸𝖊𝖉𝖎𝖆

You need 3 min read

·

Post on Jan 25, 2025

31 visitor like this post

Share

One Doom's Dark Ages: A Setback for the Franchise?

One Doom's "Dark Ages," a period roughly encompassing the games released between Doom 3 (2004) and Doom (2016), is often cited by fans as a time of creative stagnation for the franchise. While not entirely devoid of merit, this era represents a complex period of experimentation and ultimately, a setback in maintaining the series' core identity. Let's delve into the reasons why this period is considered a "dark age" and explore its impact on the Doom franchise's overall trajectory.

The Fall From Grace: Why the Dark Ages Happened

The transition from the classic Doom games to the post-Doom 3 era involved several factors contributing to this perceived downturn:

1. The Shift in Gameplay: From Arena Shooter to Survival Horror

Doom 3 marked a significant departure from the fast-paced, arena-style gameplay of its predecessors. It embraced a more atmospheric, survival horror approach, focusing on slower pacing, limited ammunition, and a heavier emphasis on environmental storytelling. While Doom 3 received positive reviews for its atmosphere and graphics, many felt it strayed too far from what made the original Doom games iconic. This shift alienated a portion of the fanbase who craved the frenetic action of the classic titles.

2. The Absence of a Strong Sequel: A Missed Opportunity

Following Doom 3, the franchise lacked a strong, immediate follow-up to capitalize on the success (relative to the shift in style). While Doom 3: BFG Edition offered a remastered experience and additional content, it didn't recapture the momentum needed to maintain the franchise’s relevance in the competitive FPS market. This gap allowed other shooters to claim market share, further contributing to the sense of a "dark age."

3. Lost Identity: The Struggle to Define Doom's Essence

The core tenets of the original Doom games—fast-paced combat, relentless monster hordes, and a sense of brutal, over-the-top action—seemed somewhat lost during this period. The attempt to reinvent the franchise with a horror-focused aesthetic, while innovative, arguably diluted the series' unique identity that had resonated with players for so long. Finding that balance would prove crucial in later iterations.

The Long Road Back: Recovering from the Setback

The release of Doom (2016) signaled a triumphant return to form. This reboot successfully addressed many of the issues that plagued the "Dark Ages," recapturing the classic gameplay mechanics while incorporating modern design principles. The game's success demonstrated that a return to the core elements of the franchise was what fans truly desired.

The Lessons Learned: A New Era for Doom

The "Dark Ages" served as a valuable learning experience for id Software. The attempt to deviate significantly from the established formula highlighted the importance of understanding and respecting the core elements that made the franchise a success in the first place. The studio learned that innovation doesn't always mean abandoning a successful foundation; it means building upon it.

The Impact on the Future: Doom Eternal and Beyond

Doom Eternal, the sequel to 2016's Doom, further solidified the franchise's return to its glory days. By building upon the successful foundation laid by the 2016 reboot, Doom Eternal delivered even more intense action and refined gameplay mechanics. The continued success of the franchise suggests that id Software has learned from its past mistakes, and that the "Dark Ages" ultimately served as a catalyst for a renewed sense of direction and creative vigor.

Conclusion: A Necessary Transition

While the "Dark Ages" of the Doom franchise presented a period of creative uncertainty and a perceived decline, it also served as a crucial learning experience. The missteps of this era ultimately paved the way for the triumphant return of the series with a renewed focus on what made it great in the first place. The period teaches valuable lessons about respecting core elements while pushing boundaries, making it an integral part of the Doom franchise's overall narrative.